In modern times our rights to a state were recognized by both powers that controlled the region and relevant international bodies. A decent argument can even be made that Jews have the right to have had included in the state of Israel land east of the Jordan River that a younger Winston Churchill and his colonial colleagues lopped off from what was then called Southern Syria or Palestine and handed to the current King Abdullah's great-grandfather, Abdullah I.
Abdullah's family, the Hashemites, ruled Mecca for 700 years and, as the Saudis were taking over Mecca, the Brits apparently thought, "hey, why not," the Hashemites can have part of Palestine or, as it was re-named, trans-Jordan. King Abdullah and the Hashemites have about as much right being there as I have performing neurosurgery.
There is also no doubt that of all the peoples in the world aspiring to nationhood, the Palestinian people, under some of the most inept, corrupt leadership imaginable, have not earned their way to the top of the list. Given opportunity after opportunity, with unprecedented financial and political support, they have opted not to develop the institutions and norms for success as a modern nation.
Among other things, they have not developed in an independent judiciary. Their press is far from free. Journalists are attacked and jailed for not towing the party line.
They have not established a free and fair electoral system. The most blatant illustration of that is 85-year-old President Abbas, who was elected to his four-year term 15 years ago. Virtually no one expects a peaceful transfer of power when he dies.
The competing Palestinian governing entities, the Palestinian Authority and Hamas, have not resolved the national divisions between their two major ideological camps, and they do not seem able to do so peacefully. In a bloody coup in 2007, Hamas took over Gaza. It controls it today, and it priorities terrorizing Israel and maintaining power over improving the lives of the inhabitants. Every attempt at peacefully reconciling and uniting Hamas and the Palestinian Authority has gone nowhere.
(continue at www.edelsteinrandomthoughts.com)